Rum, lime, almond and orange, shaken over crushed ice — the tiki classic, rebuilt around a bottle that no longer exists.
beClink Editorial·August 11, 2026
Time
5 min
Serves
1
Base
White rum
Glass
Rocks glass
Garnish
Spent lime shell and mint sprig
A mai tai is four things: rum, lime, orgeat and orange curaçao. Two of those have no non-alcoholic equivalent worth buying at the moment, which makes this the most interesting drink on the page to rebuild rather than the hardest.
The orgeat is easy — it is almond syrup, sold in any supermarket, and it was never alcoholic. The curaçao is the real gap. It was doing three jobs at once: orange flavor, sugar, and the oil-bright aroma you get off a peel. Orange juice covers the first, a bar spoon of syrup covers the second, and a dash of orange bitters covers the third. Skip the bitters and the drink tastes fine and smells of nothing, which is the part most substitutions miss.
From your kitchen: lime juice, orgeat, orange juice, crushed ice.
In this glass
Mix & Match: any 2–5 items save 5% · 6–23 save 7% · 24+ save 10%, applied automatically in your cart. Free shipping in the contiguous US, no minimum.
Make it yours
If you have an orange liqueur alternative
Use 15ml in place of the orange juice, syrup and bitters together, and it becomes the classic build. Non-alcoholic triple sec alternatives exist and are worth having if you make tiki drinks often.
Orange extract
Two drops with a bar spoon of syrup, in place of the juice. More concentrated, less dilution, and a sharper orange note.
Less sweet
Orgeat and orange juice are both carrying sugar. Drop the simple syrup entirely and lengthen the lime — the almond comes forward and the drink gets drier.
Spiced
A dash of aromatic bitters alongside the orange. It gives the drink a warmer, darker finish that suits the dark rum float.
Long
Top with soda in a tall glass. Lighter and more of an afternoon drink than an evening one.
For a crowd
Batch everything except the crushed ice and the float, and keep it cold. Build each glass to order — a mai tai sitting in melted ice is just sweet lime juice.
How to serve & pair
In a rocks glass over crushed ice, with the mint sprig where you can smell it. A mai tai is an aroma drink as much as a taste one — almond, mint and orange oil arrive before anything else does.
It suits grilled and salty food rather than sweet, and it is a late-afternoon drink. Drink it while the ice is still mounded; it goes watery faster than it looks like it will.
Common questions
What can I use instead of orange curaçao?
Orange juice with a bar spoon of simple syrup, plus two dashes of orange bitters. The juice gives you the flavor, the syrup replaces the sugar the liqueur was carrying, and the bitters give you the peel-oil aroma. Miss the bitters and the drink tastes right but smells of nothing.
What is orgeat, and do I need it?
Almond syrup, usually with a little orange flower water in it. It has never contained alcohol, so it is one ingredient that needs no substitution at all — any supermarket or online grocer sells it. Without it you have a rum sour rather than a mai tai.
Can I use grenadine instead?
It will fix the sweetness and get the flavor wrong. Grenadine is pomegranate, not orange, and it turns the drink pink. It is a common suggestion and it makes a different drink — a decent one, but not this.
Do I need two rums?
No, though the float is where a lot of the character sits — it is the first thing you taste and it keeps the drink from being uniformly sweet. One white rum alternative makes a perfectly good mai tai; the dark float makes it look and smell like the one you remember.
Rum & Tropical
